← ONLYSAPPHIC.COM

OnlySapphic Guide

Small Town Sapphic Books

One main street, two diners, and a whole town watching. Every pick here carries the small town trope, the sapphic romances where coming home, or arriving for the first time, puts the heroines right in each other’s path.

Cover of Timeless by Nicole Pyland

Timeless

NICOLE PYLAND

~4.52 ★ · 386 ratings · Paranormal Romance

A standalone reincarnation romance Pyland singles out as personally special, contemporary and historical strands follow one couple finding each other across centuries.

Cover of The Right Kind of Wrong by Monica McCallan

The Right Kind of Wrong

MONICA MCCALLAN

~4.49 ★ · 537 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Her newest release (October 2, 2026); early ratings are exceptionally high, suggesting a strong reader reception.

Cover of Changing Plans by Sienna Waters

Changing Plans

SIENNA WATERS

~4.46 ★ · 330 ratings · Medical Romance

A Whitebridge village romance pairing a locum doctor with the surgery's receptionist.

Cover of To Be With You by T.J. O'Shea

To Be With You

T.J. O'SHEA

~4.45 ★ · 979 ratings · Contemporary Romance

A Goldie finalist for Contemporary Romance: Long Novels. A star-crossed romance across the tracks: Leah Vasquez, working two jobs and desperate to leave their sleepy hometown, rescues mansion-raised Victoria Lockwood from a freak rainstorm, and both discover what they've been missing.

Cover of Cherish by Kris Bryant

Cherish

KRIS BRYANT

~4.45 ★ · 263 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Bryant's highest-rated novel: a gentle, place-first small-town romance set in Goda, Massachusetts.

Cover of The Goodmans by Clare Ashton

The Goodmans

CLARE ASHTON

~4.44 ★ · 3,170 ratings · Contemporary Romance

A sprawling family drama set on the Welsh-English border, one of Ashton's highest-rated novels in this catalog.

Cover of Heart of the Storm by Ally McGuire

Heart of the Storm

ALLY MCGUIRE

~4.39 ★ · 791 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Her joint most-rated novel (791 ratings): a New Yorker inherits a Kentucky house next door to the racing stables of a woman who swore she would never feel again.

Cover of Wasp by Cass Morgan

Wasp

CASS MORGAN

~4.39 ★ · 475 ratings · Contemporary Romance

First book of the Cycle Breaker series: a cheated-on accountant flees to her small Connecticut hometown and falls for its most hyper-independent local, over 400 Goodreads ratings in five weeks.

Cover of Gillette Park by Gerri Hill

Gillette Park

GERRI HILL

~4.38 ★ · 1,110 ratings · Paranormal Romance

Winner of the GCLS Goldie Award for Paranormal/Occult/Horror, Hill's darkest book, a supernatural thriller set in a Rocky Mountain town, and one of her highest-rated.

Cover of It's All About Bex by Melissa Tereze

It's All About Bex

MELISSA TEREZE

~4.38 ★ · 489 ratings · Erotic Romance

A standalone small-town romance from Tereze, first published in 2024.

Cover of Halcyon Nights by M.J. Duncan

Halcyon Nights

M.J. DUNCAN

~4.36 ★ · 1,615 ratings · Contemporary Romance

A standalone small-town romance set in the north woods of Minnesota.

Cover of Ribbonwood by Ruby Landers

Ribbonwood

RUBY LANDERS

~4.35 ★ · 9,415 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Winner of the 2025 GCLS Goldie Award for Best Contemporary Romance: in Ribbonwood, Australia (population 907), former soccer star Ollie Gabrielli comes home to recover from burnout and can't stop looking at Lara Bennett, her high-school nemesis and the town's reigning femme fatale, rumored to have more or less killed a man.