← ONLYSAPPHIC.COM

OnlySapphic Guide

Second Chance Sapphic Books

They had their shot once, and life had other plans. Every pick here carries the second chance trope, the sapphic love stories where the one who got away walks back in, older, sorrier and still impossible to resist.

Cover of The Piano in the Tree by Jo Havens

The Piano in the Tree

JO HAVENS

~4.66 ★ · 291 ratings · Music Romance

Winner of the 2025 Goldie Award for Best Contemporary Romance: world-famous conductor Ksenia "Toks" Tokarycz returns to Australia sixteen years after a missed Berlin train rendezvous shattered her first love, and finds cellist Polly Paterson, now a single mother, still living next door, and her piano inexplicably up a tree.

Cover of Golden Years and Silver Linings by Patricia Grayhall

Golden Years and Silver Linings

PATRICIA GRAYHALL

~4.63 ★ · 185 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Co-written with her wife Linda M. Ford, her highest-rated book (4.63): a second chance fifty years in the making, between two women in their late sixties.

Cover of Always the Planner, Never the Bride by Miranda MacLeod

Always the Planner, Never the Bride

MIRANDA MACLEOD

~4.62 ★ · 334 ratings · Wedding Romance

Co-written with T.B. Markinson. A wedding planner's second chance with the mother of the bride, a sitting lieutenant governor she was never supposed to see again.

Cover of The Touch of Her Voice by Sara Scott

The Touch of Her Voice

SARA SCOTT

~4.59 ★ · 333 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Her debut novel and the trilogy's opener: a thirteen-year relationship arc that won the 2023 National Indie Excellence Award for LGBTQIA Fiction and three Firebird first places.

Cover of Two Hit Wonder by Sienna Waters

Two Hit Wonder

SIENNA WATERS

~4.52 ★ · 152 ratings · Music Romance

Waters's highest-rated book in this catalog and her most recent release (September 2026), a second-chance music romance set around an isolated Scottish cottage.

Cover of A Choreography of Longing by T.B. Markinson

A Choreography of Longing

T.B. MARKINSON

~4.48 ★ · 743 ratings · Contemporary Romance

A standalone co-written with Miranda MacLeod by 2024 GCLS Goldie winner T.B. Markinson, a romance set inside a ballet company.

Cover of Another Stupid Love Song by Em Stevens

Another Stupid Love Song

EM STEVENS

~4.47 ★ · 682 ratings · Music Romance

A second-chance music romance, and one of MacLeod's highest-rated titles in this catalog.

Cover of The Rewind Effect by Morgan Lee Miller

The Rewind Effect

MORGAN LEE MILLER

~4.46 ★ · 213 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Miller approaches memory loss from the opposite side of her earlier novel The Memories of Marlie Rose, recovery rather than erasure, and it is her highest-rated book on Goodreads (4.51).

Cover of To Be With You by T.J. O'Shea

To Be With You

T.J. O'SHEA

~4.45 ★ · 979 ratings · Contemporary Romance

A Goldie finalist for Contemporary Romance: Long Novels. A star-crossed romance across the tracks: Leah Vasquez, working two jobs and desperate to leave their sleepy hometown, rescues mansion-raised Victoria Lockwood from a freak rainstorm, and both discover what they've been missing.

Cover of The Dommes by Cynthia Dane

The Dommes

CYNTHIA DANE

~4.45 ★ · 212 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Two Dommes, one drunken bet: Ira Mathison and Kathleen Allen, who seduced Ira twelve years ago and vanished, now work together, and the wager that the loser submits for a night lands on the woman who proposed it. The sapphic retelling of Dom Vs. Domme, with a non-binary lesbian lead.

Cover of The Tell Tale by Clare Ashton

The Tell Tale

CLARE ASHTON

~4.44 ★ · 1,033 ratings · Mystery / Thriller

A mystery set in a wintry 1970s Welsh village, among Ashton's highest-rated books in this catalog.

Cover of The One to Hold Your Hand by Erica Lee

The One to Hold Your Hand

ERICA LEE

~4.44 ★ · 717 ratings · Contemporary Romance

One of Lee's top-rated novels, a dual-timeline friends-to-lovers story.