← ONLYSAPPHIC.COM

OnlySapphic Guide

Sapphic Books with Religious Bigotry

Some readers check for religious bigotry before they pick up a book, whether they are avoiding it or looking for stories that do not flinch from it. Faith is used as a weapon in these stories, against queer characters, by churches, families or communities. Every novel here is tagged with the Religious bigotry content warning in the OnlySapphic catalog, where the warning filters let you keep titles like these on your list, or off it, as you prefer.

Cover of Backwards to Oregon by Jae

Backwards to Oregon

JAE

~4.43 ★ · 4,457 ratings · Historical Romance

Winner of the 2010 Goldie Award for Historical Romance and the opener of Jae's Oregon series, this Oregon Trail western pairs "Luke" Hamilton, a woman living as a man in 1851, with former prostitute Nora Macauley in a marriage of convenience, with young Amy in tow.

Cover of The Clinch by Nicole Disney

The Clinch

NICOLE DISNEY

~4.43 ★ · 1,479 ratings · Sports Romance

A rivals-to-lovers MMA romance, Disney's own background as a martial-arts instructor keeps the cage work authentic.

Cover of The Headmistress by Milena McKay

The Headmistress

MILENA MCKAY

~4.39 ★ · 5,177 ratings · Academic Romance

Winner of the 2022 Lambda Literary Award for Lesbian Romance and multiple Golden Crown Literary Society awards (Romantic Blend, Ann Bannon Popular Choice, cover design); her most-read book and the launch of the shared "McK-Universe."

Cover of Loser of the Year by Carrie Byrd

Loser of the Year

CARRIE BYRD

~4.38 ★ · 1,462 ratings · Workplace Romance

Byrd's debut was a 2025 Lambda Literary Award finalist for Lesbian Romance and took Best Debut honors at the Golden Crown Literary Awards: at a Catholic girls' school, drama teacher Mattie Belman and soccer coach Jillian Reed run rival programs under a morality clause.

Cover of The Senator's Wife by Jen Lyon

The Senator's Wife

JEN LYON

~4.34 ★ · 6,611 ratings · Sports Romance

Named Pencraft's Fiction Book of the Year (first place), this trilogy opener launched Lyon's bestselling series.

Cover of Who'd Have Thought by G. Benson

Who'd Have Thought

G. BENSON

~4.27 ★ · 6,820 ratings · Contemporary Romance

Winner of the 2018 Golden Crown Literary Award for Contemporary Romance: Long Novel. ER nurse Hayden Pérez answers an ad offering a fortune for a one-year wife, and discovers the bride is Samantha Thomson, the ice-queen neurosurgeon she cannot stand. Benson's most popular book, and her highest-rated in this catalog.

Cover of Her Name in the Sky by Kelly Quindlen

Her Name in the Sky

KELLY QUINDLEN

~4.26 ★ · 17,067 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Quindlen's debut novel, best friends Hannah and Baker fall for each other inside a conservative Catholic community in Louisiana, became a word-of-mouth YA staple and was reissued by Macmillan in 2026 to a starred School Library Journal review.

Cover of Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus

Gay the Pray Away

NATALIE NAUDUS

~4.26 ★ · 3,058 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

The debut novel of one of audiobook narration's most decorated voices, herself an Audie Award winner, and her own audiobook edition took an AudioFile Earphones Award and Audible Best Audiobook of the Year honours. A homeschooled teen raised in a fundamentalist Christian community falls for the new girl, Riley.

Cover of The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School by Sonora Reyes

The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School

SONORA REYES

~4.23 ★ · 33,141 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

A debut with few equals: National Book Award finalist, Lambda Literary Award winner for Young Adult, Morris Award finalist, Walter Honor Book and Pura Belpré Honor, and a national bestseller. Sixteen-year-old Yamilet Flores starts over at a Phoenix Catholic school, determined to protect her brother, and herself.

Cover of The Trip by Robin Alexander

The Trip

ROBIN ALEXANDER

~4.23 ★ · 1,170 ratings · Contemporary Romance

A multigenerational road-trip comedy (2015) across the South.

Cover of Cowboys and Kisses by Karin Kallmaker

Cowboys and Kisses

KARIN KALLMAKER

~4.22 ★ · 365 ratings · Historical Romance

Kallmaker's highest-rated novel in this catalog, named Historical Romance of the Year on the author's own site, a historical romance set on the Wyoming frontier.

Cover of Last Night at the Telegraph Club by Malinda Lo

Last Night at the Telegraph Club

MALINDA LO

~4.18 ★ · 130,347 ratings · Historical Romance

Winner of the National Book Award for Young People's Literature and the Stonewall Book Award, and a Printz Honor book: Lily Hu and Kathleen Miller fall for each other in 1954 San Francisco Chinatown, under the shadow of the Red Scare.