← ONLYSAPPHIC.COM

OnlySapphic Guide

Best Sapphic YA Audiobooks

First love, first everything. Every pick here sits in the young adult and new adult genre, the sapphic coming-of-age stories readers rated highest: school corridors, first apartments, and the girl who changes the whole plan. This is the listening version of the shelf: every pick here is available as an audiobook, ready to play.

Cover of Where You'll Find Us by Jen St. Jude

Where You'll Find Us

JEN ST. JUDE

~4.63 ★ · 217 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Publishers Weekly called St. Jude's second novel 'a layered, cathartic story about a transgender teen': disowned by their parents, Cal and girlfriend Ramona find Amaranth, a farmhouse outside time where queer kids from every era are safe.

Cover of Love Forged by Nicole Pyland

Love Forged

NICOLE PYLAND

~4.35 ★ · 542 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

A new-adult standalone, first published in 2021, a friends-to-lovers story about travel and self-discovery.

Cover of Losing Sam by Nicole Maser

Losing Sam

NICOLE MASER

~4.31 ★ · 4,098 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Her debut novel and the Losing Sam opener: a coming-out romance built around a strict Christian college ambition and a rehab-center volunteer post.

Cover of Her Name in the Sky by Kelly Quindlen

Her Name in the Sky

KELLY QUINDLEN

~4.26 ★ · 17,067 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Quindlen's debut novel, best friends Hannah and Baker fall for each other inside a conservative Catholic community in Louisiana, became a word-of-mouth YA staple and was reissued by Macmillan in 2026 to a starred School Library Journal review.

Cover of Gay the Pray Away by Natalie Naudus

Gay the Pray Away

NATALIE NAUDUS

~4.26 ★ · 3,058 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

The debut novel of one of audiobook narration's most decorated voices, herself an Audie Award winner, and her own audiobook edition took an AudioFile Earphones Award and Audible Best Audiobook of the Year honours. A homeschooled teen raised in a fundamentalist Christian community falls for the new girl, Riley.

Cover of Donut Summer by Anita Kelly

Donut Summer

ANITA KELLY

~4.24 ★ · 387 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Kelly's highest-rated book: a YA romance set behind the counter of a small-town donut shop.

Cover of The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School by Sonora Reyes

The Lesbiana's Guide to Catholic School

SONORA REYES

~4.23 ★ · 33,141 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

A debut with few equals: National Book Award finalist, Lambda Literary Award winner for Young Adult, Morris Award finalist, Walter Honor Book and Pura Belpré Honor, and a national bestseller. Sixteen-year-old Yamilet Flores starts over at a Phoenix Catholic school, determined to protect her brother, and herself.

Cover of A Story of Now by Emily O'Beirne

A Story of Now

EMILY O'BEIRNE

~4.21 ★ · 816 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Book one of O'Beirne's A Story of Now series, a Melbourne-set YA coming-out story from the Australian author.

Cover of Girl Made of Stars by Ashley Herring Blake

Girl Made of Stars

ASHLEY HERRING BLAKE

~4.18 ★ · 30,094 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

A Lambda Literary Award finalist, this unflinching YA novel places a bisexual teen between family loyalty and justice when her twin brother is accused by her best friend.

Cover of Loveless by Alice Oseman

Loveless

ALICE OSEMAN

~4.16 ★ · 125,361 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Georgia starts university certain romance is waiting for her, and has to unlearn the script when the words asexual and aromantic finally explain her. The defining aro-ace coming-of-age novel, warm and funny about the love that is not romance.

Cover of Imogen, Obviously by Becky Albertalli

Imogen, Obviously

BECKY ALBERTALLI

~4.16 ★ · 32,616 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Albertalli's highest-rated book: her most personal standalone, written in the wake of her own experience of being pushed to publicly examine her sexuality.

Cover of Not My Problem by Ciara Smyth

Not My Problem

CIARA SMYTH

~4.09 ★ · 18,065 ratings · Young Adult / New Adult

Smyth's follow-up turns its heroine into her school's fixer, a favors-for-hire scheme born from pushing her overachieving nemesis down the stairs, and it is her highest-rated novel (4.09).